444 Fire Island Avenue, Babylon, NY

$999,000

Previous Next

1,450

Square feet

About 444 Fire Island Avenue

Introducing a rare opportunity to acquire a historic waterfront restaurant property in the heart of Babylon Village. Located at 444 Fire Island Avenue, this site was formerly home to the renowned Pier 44 Restaurant, a beloved dockside destination that operated successfully for over three decades, serving seafood and American cuisine with scenic views of the Great South Bay. Positioned near the Babylon Village marina and surrounded by an active boating community, the property offers an exceptional setting for a reimagined waterfront dining experience. While the existing building requires rehabilitation, the location and history provide a remarkable foundation for a visionary buyer to create a signature waterfront restaurant, hospitality concept, or destination venue. With the right vision, this property can once again become one of Babylon Village’s premier waterfront destinations, blending its rich history with a new and elevated dining experience.

Features of 444 Fire Island Avenue

MLS® # 967680
Price $999,000
Square Footage 1,450
Taxes $31,048
Type Commercial Sale
Sub-Type Other
Status Active

Community Information

Address 444 Fire Island Avenue
City Babylon
County Suffolk County
State NY
Zip Code 11702
Adult 55+ Community No

Amenities

Utilities Electricity Connected, Natural Gas Connected
Parking Spaces 15
Parking Parking Lot
Is Waterfront No
Has Pool No

Interior

Heating Forced Air
Cooling Zoned
Has Basement No
Fireplace No
# of Stories 1

Exterior

Lot Description Level
Exterior Frame

Additional Information

Date Listed March 5th, 2026
Days on Market 218
Short Sale No
RE / Bank Owned No
Floor 1

Listing Details

OfficeColdwell Banker American Homes
Contact Info516-864-8100

Listing Map

Request a Showing

Provide a valid email address.
When would you like to view this property?